• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum, LLP

MENUMENU
  • Home
  • Our Attorneys
        • Dennis J. Phillips
        • Daniel J. Hogan
        • Melissa Dwyer Lescault
        • Courtney M. Haskins
        • Vanessa A. Hutton
        • William E. Fitzgerald
        • John E. Fitzgerald, Jr.
        • Dennis J. O’Connor
        • Eric C. Schwenker
        • Dmitri Yepikhin
        • James E. Cullum
        • Timothy S. Shuler
        • Edward P. Fitzgerald
        • Brian Borie
        • Dennis J. Philips
          Dennis J. Philips
        • James E. Cullum
          James E. Cullum
        • William E. Fitzgerald
          William E. Fitzgerald
        • Daniel J. Hogan
          Daniel J. Hogan
        • Timothy S. Schuler
          Timothy S. Schuler
        • Melissa Dwyer Lescault
          Melissa Dwyer Lescault
        • Dennis J. O'Conner
          Dennis J. O'Conner
        • Edward P. Fitzgerald
          Edward P. Fitzgerald
        • Courtney M. Haskins
          Courtney M. Haskins
        • Eric C. Schwenker
          Eric C. Schwenker
        • Mary K. Coseo
          Mary K. Coseo
        • John E. Fitzgerald, Jr.
          John E. Fitzgerald, Jr.
        • Stephen L. Perkins
          Stephen L. Perkins
        • Brian C. Borie
          Brian C. Borie
        • Vanessa A. Hutton
          Vanessa A. Hutton
        • Dmitri Yepikhin
          Dmitri Yepikhin
  • Practice Areas
    • Banking
    • Business & Commercial Law
    • Construction Law
    • Corporations, LLCs & Partnerships
    • Criminal Defense
    • Driving While Intoxicated
    • Elder Law, Medicare & Medicaid
    • Employment Discrimination
    • Environmental Law
    • Estate & Asset Transfer Planning
    • Estate & Trust Administration
    • Insurance Law
    • Land Use Planning & Zoning
    • Landlord & Tenant
    • Medical Malpractice Defense
    • Motor Vehicle Accidents
    • Not for Profit
    • Personal Injury
    • Premises Liability
    • Probate
    • Product Liability
    • Real Estate
    • Real Property Disputes
    • Slip & Fall
    • Tax Assessment
    • Vehicle & Traffic Violations
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
    • Glens Falls, New York OfficeThe firm has been located in downtown Glens Falls, New York ever since its founding in 1911 by James McPhillips and C.E. Fitzgerald.
    • Glens Falls, New York Office
    • Miami Shores, Florida OfficeOur Miami Shores, Florida office allows McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum, LLP to give our Florida resident clients personal and focused attention.
    • Miami Shores, Florida Office
New York·518-792-1174
Florida·305-751-8556

Automobile Damage FAQ

Should I purchase any extra insurance on the rental car provided to me?

Your own insurance policy should cover you while driving the rental car, but you should call your insurance agent to be sure that you are covered. The other driver's insurance company is not required to pay for additional insurance if you choose to purchase it from the car rental company.

What kind of rental car am I entitled to?

The insurance company has to pay for the reasonably incurred rental cost of a substitute vehicle. Often, there are disputes as to what qualifies as a "substitute" vehicle. Essentially, it should be a vehicle of similar quality, within the confines of what is available for rent.

What if I need a rental car? Do I have to pay for it while my car is being repaired?

If you caused the accident, or if there is a dispute over who is to blame, then you must either pay for the rental car yourself or seek coverage under your own insurance policy if rental coverage is available. Many insurance contracts do not provide for rental coverage for their own customers, so you need to contact your insurance agent to determine what coverage exists. If the other driver is at fault, then we will demand that the insurance company for the person who caused the accident provide you with a rental car for the time needed to repair your vehicle. Sometimes, you must pay the rental car bill first, with reimbursement coming from the insurance company later.

What about license and registration fees that I had to pay to drive the car?

In order to drive your vehicle, you had to pay a tag fee and registration fees. In some states, you are entitled to be reimbursed for the prorated amount of these costs that are unused. The insurance company may reimburse you for tag transfer fees and, in some cases, a prorated amount of sales tax on the actual cash value of the car at the time of the accident. Contact a Florida auto accident lawyer to learn whether license and registration fees are recoverable in your case.

Will I have to pay the towing and storage costs?

In most cases, unless there is a dispute as to who was at fault in the accident, the insurance company for the driver who caused the accident will pay the reasonable towing and storage costs (if necessary) of your car. After evaluating the vehicle, if the insurance company declares the car a total loss, they will have the car moved to a wrecking yard or a free storage area. If you refuse to allow the insurance company to move your car, however, you will have to pay the storage costs from the day of your refusal forward, or you can pay to have it towed to your home.

What if my car already had some damage before the accident?

If your vehicle had damage to it prior to the accident, it can be difficult to determine exactly what portion of the damage was caused by the accident itself. For example, if your car has a mechanical problem, the insurance company may claim that it existed prior to the accident if some evidence indicates that there was substantial wear and tear. Therefore, it is important that you prove the connection between the auto accident and the damage you are claiming. Ordinarily, mechanics and collision repair personnel can help to prove the age of body damage or the cause of a mechanical failure. They can assist to convince the insurance company that the auto accident caused the damage you are claiming.

What kind of parts will be used in the repair?

You have the right to demand that only original manufacturer parts be used in the repair, so if your car is a Chevrolet, you should receive genuine Chevrolet (GM) parts. Since your car was probably not new at the time of the accident, however, the mechanic may use refurbished or reconditioned parts.

Can I choose my own repair shop?

Yes. You always have the right to decide who will repair your vehicle, however the cost of the repair is not always determined by the estimate given by the repair facility of your choosing.

What if I am “upside down” on the loan for my car?

If you owe more money on the loan for the car than the fair market value of the car, you are "upside down" on the loan. Unfortunately, if your vehicle is a total loss, the insurance company is not required to pay more money to you simply because you are "upside down" with your car loan. They are only obligated to pay the "fair market value" of your car.

How is the market value of my car determined?

You are entitled to recover the "fair market value" or the "actual cash value" of your vehicle immediately before the accident. One common source used to estimate fair market value is the Kelley Blue Book. Other sources of information are the local newspaper or the Auto Trader, which may list the for-sale price of cars of the same make, model, and year as yours. Occasionally, an expert vehicle appraiser is used to help prove the value of your vehicle.

Can I control whether my car is repaired or replaced?

This can be a difficult issue. For most people, getting back into their own vehicle, so long as it is safe, is a priority. Normally, the insurance company has the option to either repair or replace your vehicle, depending on whether it costs less to replace your vehicle than to repair it. If this is the case, the insurance company will declare your vehicle a "total loss," and take action to replace your vehicle. If your car is declared a "total loss," the insurance company buys your car for its market value (see below), which can be difficult to determine. If you wish to keep the wrecked car, you may purchase it back from the insurance company for its salvage value. The insurance adjuster can deduct the salvage value from the settlement and you can keep the car.

Often the situation is reversed, and the insurance company chooses to repair a vehicle rather than replace it. In this case, if you are concerned about the safety of the repaired vehicle, you should contact our office to discuss your options.

Primary Sidebar

Schedule Your Consultation

Submit this form to schedule a consultation with an experienced attorney at McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum, LLP. We will respect the confidentiality of your information to the fullest extent.
  • * - Required Fields · Privacy Policy
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Footer

Glens Falls, New York Office
288 Glen St
PO Box 299
Glens Falls, NY 12801

Phone: 518-792-1174
Fax: 518-792-1675

Miami Shores, Florida Office
9999 NE 2nd Ave
Suite 200
Miami Shores, FL 33138

Phone: 305-751-8556
Fax: 518-792-1675

Chestertown
Office

102 Riverside Drive
Chestertown,
New York 12817

Phone: 518-792-1174
Fax: 518-792-1675

  • Home
  • Our Attorneys
  • Practice Areas
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

Serving Warren, Washington, Saratoga, Essex, Hamilton, Albany, Rensselaer and Schenectady counties, including all of the North Country in New York and Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach and Sarasota counties in Florida

Copyright © 2023 · McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum, LLP & Altrumedia, LLC · All Rights Reserved · Attorney Advertising