How Pure Comparative Negligence Laws Affect My Injury Case
content.team • February 15, 2024

February 15, 2024

After you suffer injuries or lose a loved one in an accident, you can recover compensation for expenses and other damages if you can prove negligence in your  injury case. In New York, awards for compensation are made based on pure comparative negligence laws. This was true also in Florida. However, in 2023, the laws changed to a modified comparative negligence system. Modified comparative negligence bars injured parties from recovering compensation if they are more than 51% at fault for the accident. Pure comparative negligence is different.

What Is Pure Comparative Negligence?

The court uses the tort principle of comparative negligence to determine the amount of damages in the form of compensation you can recover for your injuries and losses in an injury case. If the at-fault party was 100% at fault, you can recover 100% of the damages awarded to you.

If the court determines that you were partially at fault for your injuries, you can recover a percentage of the damages the court awards you. For example, you were traveling five miles over the speed limit. The defendant ran a stop sign and caused your injuries. Let’s say the court determines that you were 20% at fault for the accident because you were going five miles over the speed limit.

The court also determined that you should recover $100,000 for your injuries. Because the court made the determination that you were 20% at fault, you can only recover 80% of the $100,000 awarded amount.

With pure comparative negligence, you have the ability to recover compensation for the damages caused by the defendant so long as you are not 100% at fault. This means that even if you are 99% at fault for an accident, you can still recover compensation for the 1% of damages suffered due to the fault of the other party.

Determining Fault

Injury laws, including comparative negligence laws, are complex. For the court to determine you were partially at fault, the defendant must be able to prove you were partially negligent. In this case, speeding is often considered negligent – you had a duty to keep others and yourself safe, you breached that duty by speeding, you contributed to your own injuries when you breached that duty, and you have damages. It is best to work with our skilled attorneys to prove the defendant was responsible so that you can recover the maximum possible compensation for your damages.

Schedule a Consultation Today

McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum LLP serves Glens Falls, Chestertown and the surrounding areas in New York and Miami Shores and the surrounding areas in Florida. To find out more about your injury case, speak with an attorney at McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum LLP. To  schedule a consultation , please call 518-792-1174 in Glens Falls and Chestertown or 305-751-8556 in Miami Shores.

< Older Post

 Newer Post >
Why Some Injury Claims Take Longer Than lawyer discussion with client gavel pen and law scale on the table

Why Some Injury Claims Take Longer Than Others to Resolve

By shreya kapoor • February 15, 2026
When an accident causes serious harm, many people expect injury claims to resolve quickly. Delays can be frustrating, especially as medical expenses and lost income continue to grow. In reality, the timeline for resolving injury claims varies widely depending on several important factors, and a longer process does not necessarily mean something has gone wrong. Established in 1911, […] The post Why Some Injury Claims Take Longer Than Others to Resolve appeared first on McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum LLP.
A person wearing a neck brace and arm sling sits at a desk with paperwork and a pen.

What Happens When An Insurance Company Denies Your Injury Claim

By content.team • January 15, 2026
A letter denying an injury claim can be frightening, especially as medical bills mount and missed paychecks add up. For people in Glens Falls and Chestertown, New York, and Miami Shores, Florida, a denied insurance claim after a product-related accident often raises urgent questions about what to do next.  McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum LLP has represented clients in the […] The post What Happens When An Insurance Company Denies Your Injury Claim appeared first on McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum LLP.
A person holding their head in pain after stepping out of a blue car with a deployed airbag and smoke in the background.

Third-Party Liability: When Someone Other Than The Driver Is To Blame

By content.team • December 15, 2025
After a motor vehicle accident, many people assume that only the drivers involved can be held responsible. In reality, a careless company, property owner, or government entity may also contribute to the crash. McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum LLP, established in 1911, is the longest-serving law firm in the Greater Glens Falls region and holds Martindale-Hubbell’s highest AV rating for […] The post Third-Party Liability: When Someone Other Than The Driver Is To Blame appeared first on McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum LLP.
Show More →