Workers’ Comp or Personal Injury?
kyle.larson • July 15, 2022

July 15, 2022

Workers’ Comp or Personal Injury?

When you are injured on the job, you may have the option to choose between pursuing compensation through an insurance program like workers’ comp or taking legal action through a  personal injury claim. This is largely dependent on the nature of your work, the extent of your injury, and the circumstances surrounding your accident.

Who is Eligible for Workers’ Compensation?

In the state of Florida, all employers with four or more employees must carry workers’ comp insurance. In New York, all businesses, regardless of the number of employees, must carry this insurance.

Workers’ comp is no-fault insurance. This means that even if your actions played a role in your accident, you will be entitled to seek compensation for medical expenses and a portion of your lost wages until you have recovered enough to return to work. Due to this, workers’ comp is a good fit for many workplace injuries.

You are not eligible for workers’ compensation if you are an independent contractor. This is particularly problematic in the  construction industry  where many workers are labeled “contract.” If you are a contract worker who has been injured on the job, you will not be able to seek no-fault compensation.

Which is Better?

Both workers’ comp and personal injury law are helpful for injured workers. Which option is right for your situation is related to factors specific to your case. It can be useful to discuss your case with an experienced personal injury lawyer who can review the details of your accident and provide straightforward answers about the best way to proceed. Neither option is suitable for every situation.

For a personal injury lawsuit to be viable, there must be a negligent party. This can complicate the claims process and may result in a delay of funds. Having a lawyer who understands both what you need right now and what you will need in the future can help you understand if pursuing this action is worth your while.

Contact Us for Help

Please call  518-792-1174  to schedule a complimentary consultation with one of the attorneys at McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum. We maintain offices in New York and Florida.

Why Some Injury Claims Take Longer Than 
lawyer discussion with client gavel pen and law scale on the table
By shreya kapoor February 15, 2026
When an accident causes serious harm, many people expect injury claims to resolve quickly. Delays can be frustrating, especially as medical expenses and lost income continue to grow. In reality, the timeline for resolving injury claims varies widely depending on several important factors, and a longer process does not necessarily mean something has gone wrong. Established in 1911, […] The post Why Some Injury Claims Take Longer Than Others to Resolve appeared first on McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum LLP.
A person wearing a neck brace and arm sling sits at a desk with paperwork and a pen.
By content.team January 15, 2026
A letter denying an injury claim can be frightening, especially as medical bills mount and missed paychecks add up. For people in Glens Falls and Chestertown, New York, and Miami Shores, Florida, a denied insurance claim after a product-related accident often raises urgent questions about what to do next.  McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum LLP has represented clients in the […] The post What Happens When An Insurance Company Denies Your Injury Claim appeared first on McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum LLP.
A person holding their head in pain after stepping out of a blue car with a deployed airbag and smoke in the background.
By content.team December 15, 2025
After a motor vehicle accident, many people assume that only the drivers involved can be held responsible. In reality, a careless company, property owner, or government entity may also contribute to the crash. McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum LLP, established in 1911, is the longest-serving law firm in the Greater Glens Falls region and holds Martindale-Hubbell’s highest AV rating for […] The post Third-Party Liability: When Someone Other Than The Driver Is To Blame appeared first on McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum LLP.
Show More →