• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum, LLP

MENUMENU
  • Home
  • Our Attorneys
        • Dennis J. Phillips
        • Daniel J. Hogan
        • Melissa Dwyer Lescault
        • Courtney M. Haskins
        • Brian Borie
        • Vanessa A. Hutton
        • William E. Fitzgerald
        • John E. Fitzgerald, Jr.
        • Dennis J. O’Connor
        • Eric C. Schwenker
        • James E. Cullum
        • Timothy S. Shuler
        • Edward P. Fitzgerald
        • Stephen L. Perkins
        • Dennis J. Philips
          Dennis J. Philips
        • James E. Cullum
          James E. Cullum
        • William E. Fitzgerald
          William E. Fitzgerald
        • Daniel J. Hogan
          Daniel J. Hogan
        • Timothy S. Schuler
          Timothy S. Schuler
        • Melissa Dwyer Lescault
          Melissa Dwyer Lescault
        • Dennis J. O'Conner
          Dennis J. O'Conner
        • Edward P. Fitzgerald
          Edward P. Fitzgerald
        • Courtney M. Haskins
          Courtney M. Haskins
        • Eric C. Schwenker
          Eric C. Schwenker
        • Mary K. Coseo
          Mary K. Coseo
        • John E. Fitzgerald, Jr.
          John E. Fitzgerald, Jr.
        • Stephen L. Perkins
          Stephen L. Perkins
        • Brian C. Borie
          Brian C. Borie
  • Practice Areas
    • Banking
    • Business & Commercial Law
    • Construction Law
    • Corporations, LLCs & Partnerships
    • Criminal Defense
    • Driving While Intoxicated
    • Elder Law, Medicare & Medicaid
    • Employment Discrimination
    • Environmental Law
    • Estate & Asset Transfer Planning
    • Estate & Trust Administration
    • Insurance Law
    • Land Use Planning & Zoning
    • Landlord & Tenant
    • Medical Malpractice Defense
    • Motor Vehicle Accidents
    • Not for Profit
    • Personal Injury
    • Premises Liability
    • Probate
    • Product Liability
    • Real Estate
    • Real Property Disputes
    • Slip & Fall
    • Tax Assessment
    • Vehicle & Traffic Violations
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
    • Glens Falls, New York OfficeThe firm has been located in downtown Glens Falls, New York ever since its founding in 1911 by James McPhillips and C.E. Fitzgerald.
    • Glens Falls, New York Office
    • Miami Shores, Florida OfficeOur Miami Shores, Florida office allows McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum, LLP to give our Florida resident clients personal and focused attention.
    • Miami Shores, Florida Office
New York·518-792-1174
Florida·305-751-8556

Do Landlords Who Don’t Allow Pets Have to Allow Service Dogs and Emotional Support Animals?

December 28, 2018 by McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum, LLP

The short answer is, yes. It’s a confusing topic for landlords, renters and other interested parties, because most people are at least somewhat familiar with the subject of service animals and their protection under the American with Disabilities Act (ADA) and the fact that emotional support animals (ESAs) are not protected. So, for instance, restaurants are not required to allow emotional support cats, but they are required to allow seizure alert dogs. When it comes to housing, though, the protections are much broader, as they should be. The ADA still applies, but so does the Fair Housing Act (FHA) which requires landlords to permit assistance animals, including ESAs, and states that any type of animal can qualify, not just dogs.

Medical Requirement

Under the FHA, a landlord can require documentation showing that you do have a disability and that you need your assistance animal to help you with some aspect of your disability. A letter from your doctor is adequate. Landlords are not allowed to request your medical records or to speak to your health care professional directly.

Animal Documentation

No special training or certification is required for your animal to qualify as an assistance animal. Landlords cannot require or even request certification. However, landlords can require documentation showing that your service or assistance animal has the legally required vaccinations.

Service Animals and Assistance Animals are Not Pets

Assistance animals and service animals are not pets. Landlords that charge a pet deposit and/or fees cannot apply these charges to service or assistance animals. Animal owners are responsible for any damage caused by the animal.

Owners are also responsible for cleaning up waste and keeping their service and assistance animals under control. Landlords are not required to tolerate tenants who fail to do so. Letting them runs loose or bark excessively can be grounds for eviction, just as with pets.

Landlords cannot impose breed, size or weight limitations on assistance animals. Local breed bans do not apply to service animals or assistance animals and are not an excuse for landlords discriminate based on breed. Nor do breed or size constitute safety threats. Safety threats can only be based on the individual animal’s behavior and history.

Service animals have more rights than assistance animals. ESAs are assistance animals, not service animals, but landlords need to be aware that there are also psychiatric service animals. Landlords must allow service animals in public areas, such as pools or community rooms, but do not have to allow assistance animals in these areas.

Why Landlords and Tenants Need Legal Advice

There are multiple, overlapping laws that apply to the subject of service animals and assistance animals in housing. Neither landlords nor tenants should try to figure it out on their own. Many of these laws appear to contradict each other and, as with all things legal, there are some exceptions to the basic requirements.

As a tenant, you need to know your rights and if the housing you are in or trying to move into is covered. For example, the FHA covers most housing, but there are a few exceptions including:

  • Owner-occupied buildings with no more than four units
  • Single-family housing sold or rented without the use of a broker if the private individual owner does not own more than three such single-family homes at one time
  • Housing operated by religious organizations and private clubs that limit occupancy to members

Also, as a tenant you need to understand your responsibilities and the limitations that apply to your rights. For instance, assistance animals do not have all of the rights granted to service animals, even though landlords must permit them in your home. And, landlords are not required to do things like build a fence specifically for you and your service animal. As the owner, you are still responsible for cleaning up after your animal and making sure that your animal behaves properly, even if it is a service dog or assistance animal.

If you are a landlord, you need to consult with an attorney to avoid running afoul of the many federal, state and local discrimination laws, and to understand when you can or cannot be held liable if a tenant’s service or assistance animal hurts someone. Don’t assume that you can turn a tenant away because you fall under an exception to one or more of the laws that require landlords to allow these animals. You may still be required to do so by another law. The most common mistake is understanding your rights and responsibilities under the ADA and not realizing that you must also comply with the FHA.o learn more about your rights and responsibilities regarding service animals and assistance animals, as a tenant or landlord, please call or contact us today and schedule your confidential initial consultation.

Filed Under: Blog · Tagged With: Landlord & Tenant

Primary Sidebar

Schedule Your Consultation

Submit this form to schedule a consultation with an experienced attorney at McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum, LLP. We will respect the confidentiality of your information to the fullest extent.
  • * - Required Fields · Privacy Policy
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Footer

Glens Falls, New York Office
288 Glen St
PO Box 299
Glens Falls, NY 12801

Phone: 518-792-1174
Fax: 518-792-1675

Miami Shores, Florida Office
9999 NE 2nd Ave
Suite 200
Miami Shores, FL 33138

Phone: 305-751-8556
Fax: 518-792-1675

Chestertown
Office

102 Riverside Drive
Chestertown,
New York 12817

Phone: 518-792-1174
Fax: 518-792-1675

  • Home
  • Our Attorneys
  • Practice Areas
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

Serving Warren, Washington, Saratoga, Essex, Hamilton, Albany, Rensselaer and Schenectady counties, including all of the North Country in New York and Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach and Sarasota counties in Florida

Copyright © 2021 · McPhillips, Fitzgerald & Cullum, LLP & Altrumedia, LLC · All Rights Reserved · Attorney Advertising